Shop the best farms selling baked cookies in Webster, New York. Updated July 2026. Elly's Acres Farm, Jelliff's Maple, and more.

Elly's Acres Farm

John

This item is $13.00 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 1.82 and 5 lbs.
The estimated price is between $23.66 and $65.00

Lamb, Bone-In Leg

We produce succulent, nutritious pasture-raised, grass-fed, premium lamb from the lush green pastures of the central New York hill country. High in niacin, iron, zinc, vitamins B6 and 12, selenium, and omega 6 fatty acids, our lamb transfers this nutrition directly to you off of our fertile pastures. Raised with your health, nutrition, enjoyment and peace of mind that our flock is ethically and responsibly cared for, we don’t do any of the following:

No electric prods
No grain finishing (this means you are buying meat, not fat)
No dry lot feeding (our sheep and lambs are not confined to industrial barns & instead roam the countryside)
No Antibiotics
No growth hormones
No animal by-products

Lamb, Ground

 Lamb, Heart

Lamb, Kidney

This item is $15.00 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 1.4 and 3 lbs.
The estimated price is between $21.00 and $45.00

Lamb leg, Boneless

Lamb, Liver .5-1 lb

Lamb, Loin Chops

 Lamb, Mild Italian Sausage

Lamb, Rack

Lamb, Rib Chops

Jelliff's Maple

Greg

Unit size is per 250 ml

If you like coffe you are going to enjoy our Coffee Bean Infused Maple Syrup. Adds a distinct mellow coffee flavor to whatever you put it on. Our flavored syrups can be used anyway maple syrup is used. Delicious on desserts and ice cream.

Coffee Bean Infused Maple Syrup

Unit size is per 1 box

Now you can enjoy our award winning chicken wings right at home.  Included:  Maple Mustard with a Kick; Maple BBQ; Maple Sweet Heat; Maple Dust All Purpose Seasoning; Maple Dust BBQ Rub; Recipe Card containing all 3 winning recipes. (Chicken wings not included)

Gift Box-Winning Wings

Unit size is per 16 oz fl

Seasoned just right.  Our BBQ Sauce is a number 1 seller!  Enjoyed so much by our costomers they requested that we offer it in a larger quanity.  They asked...we listened.  It is now available for purchase in a half gallon size too.  This  favorite  is enjoyed on grilled pork chops, hot roast beef sandwich, pulled pork, grilled chicken, meatloaf and of course chicken wings just to name a few.

Jelliff's original recipe - not made from a BBQ based product. 

Maple Barbecue Sauce

Unit size is per 84 oz

Seasoned just right.  Our BBQ Sauce is a number 1 seller!  Enjoyed so much by our costomers they requested that we offer it in a larger quanity.  They asked...we listened.  It is now available for purchase in a half gallon size too.  This  favorite  is enjoyed on grilled pork chops, hot roast beef sandwich, pulled pork, grilled chicken, meatloaf and of course chicken wings just to name a few.

Jelliff's original recipe - not made from a BBQ based product.

If you liked our Maple Caramels you are going to LOVE this Maple Caramel Dip.  Our made from scratch recipe is made in small batches to maintain the delicious, creamy goodness.  Perfect for apples, pretzels, ice cream, mixing with your cream cheese frosting for a decadent cinnamon roll glaze.  Or, as one customer said..."it's great by the spoon full".

Maple Caramel Dip

Unit size is per 12 oz

This delicious coffee is roasted with real maple syrup.  The aroma will draw you to it  but the flavor will make you say, “Wow” and keep you coming back for more!  Enjoy a brewed cup today!

Maple Coffee

Unit size is per 8 oz

For a special treat, sprinkled on cereal, toast, bagels with cream cheese, fruit, yogurt, sweet potatoes. Use as a sweetener for your coffee or tea. Delicious on baked goods and a perfect topping for ice cream. 

Maple Crumbles

Unit size is per 2 oz

Great for all your BBQ needs. Spicy with a little heat.  Use on beef, ribs, pork, pulled meats, chicken wings...try it you will like it!  Our customers asked...we delivered!

Maple Dust Spicy BBQ Rub

Unit size is per 2pc pkg

"Pet tested - Owner approved"

Milk-Bone Dog Bones encrusted with Pure Maple Syrup.

Maple Encrusted Dog Bones

Unit size is per 8 oz

Our Maple French Dressing was created by converting an old family recipe. This healthier version is made with homemade ketchup using maple sugar. You won’t find any “high fructose“ in this one. Our Maple French Dressing is a big hit in many homes.

Maple French Dressing

Russell Farms

The perfect box for fruit lovers!

5 Eating Apples

4 Pears (Green or Red)

2 Jumbo Navel Oranges

1.5 lb Mixed Green and Red Grapes

1 Pint Blueberries

1 Half Pint Raspberries

1 Pint Strawberries

In an event that product availabilty is limited we will make a product substitution.

Fruit Lovers Box

The box to keep your immune system strong!

1 Bunch Bananas

2 Lemons

2 Limes

2 Kiwi

2 Avocados

2 Navel Oranges

2 Grapefruit

1 Pineapple

In an event that product availabilty is limited we will make a product substitution.


Immunity Booster Box

Rye Bread Bowl and Dip Party Platter

All the essential veggies in one box!

1 Stalk of Celery

1 Garlic Clove

2 Broccoli Crowns

1 Head Hydro Lettuce

2 Zuchinni

2 Slicing Cucumbers

2 Beefsteak Tomatoes

2 Baking Potatoes

1 Sweet Onion

1 QT Green Beans

1 Green Pepper

1 Red Pepper

In an event that product availabilty is limited we will make a product substitution.

Veggie Lovers Box

This item is $10.99 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 2 and 4 lbs.
The estimated price is between $21.98 and $43.96

Unit size is per each

Local grass fed beef produced by Russell Farms

Local Grass Fed Beef - Bottom Round Roast

This item is $9.99 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 2 and 4 lbs.
The estimated price is between $19.98 and $39.96

Local grass fed beef produced by Russell Farms.  Frozen

Local Grass Fed Beef - Brisket

This item is $13.99 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 1.5 and 3.5 lbs.
The estimated price is between ~$20.99 and ~$48.97

Local grass fed beef raised on our farm.  Frozen

Local Grass Fed Beef - Chuck Steak, bone-in

This item is $8.99 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 0.75 and 1.25 lbs.
The estimated price is between ~$6.74 and ~$11.24

Russell Farms grass fed ground beef approx 1lb package

Local Grass Fed Beef, Ground Beef

Unit size is per 1 bag

Local fresh cut arugula

Arugula, Local

Fresh asparagus aprox 3/4 pound per bunch.

Asparagus - Bunch

Forks Farm & Market

Plentiful in protein and iron, the Beef Liver has a rich flavor. Great to pan-fry!

100% Grass Fed Beef, Liver

10 lbs. of ground pasture raised organically fed turkeys. 

Pasture- Raised Ground Turkey Organically fed- 10 lbs. (bulk discount)

This item is $4.50 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 2.75 and 5.25 lbs.
The estimated price is between ~$12.38 and ~$23.63

Plump, juicy roasting chickens, organically fed, moved to fresh pasture every day. Great for roasting & grilling. 

Pasture-Raised, Organically Fed Chicken, Whole

This item is $11.25 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 1 and 2.5 lbs.
The estimated price is between $11.25 and ~$28.13

Unit size is per 2 pack

This pack of two shoulder chops (also known as blade chops) is perfect for a quick, delicious meal. They are juicy and tender when cooked medium to rare. 

Grass-Fed Lamb, Chops (Shoulder)

This item is $12.50 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 6 and 9 lbs.
The estimated price is between $75.00 and $112.50

Enjoy our delicious grass-fed whole leg of lamb!

Lamb, Leg (Whole)

This item is $17.25 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 0.25 and 2 lbs.
The estimated price is between ~$4.31 and $34.50

Cut 1" thick. One of our most popular beef steaks. Grill, pan fry, or broil!

100% Grass Fed Beef, Delmonico Rib Eye Steak

This item is $9.50 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 2 and 3 lbs.
The estimated price is between $19.00 and $28.50

2-3 lb Roast. A popular Winter roast to make your favorite Pot Roast recipe.

100% Grass Fed Beef, Eye of the Round Roast

This item is $5.00 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 1 and 2.5 lbs.
The estimated price is between $5.00 and $12.50

Meaty Shank Soup Bones, great for soups and stews. 1.50 lb. avg.

100% Grass Fed Beef, Meaty Soup Bones/ Shank

This item is $16.00 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 1.5 and 1.75 lbs.
The estimated price is between $24.00 and $28.00

The strip on one side, tenderloin on the other. One of the most prized cuts in the loin. 1 per pack.

100% Grass Fed Beef, Porterhouse Steak

German Summer Sausage (Beef). Slice and eat. All organic seasonings. 1.00 lb. avg.

100% Grass Fed Beef, Sausage (German Summer)

Sinking Creek Meats

Chris

How do you make the BEST hot dogs better??? You add CHEESE!!   6 per pack.

All-Beef Cheese Dogs

1 oz snack stick, shelf stable and perfect for a snack on the go!

Sinking Creek Hot Snack Stick

Sinking Creek Sweet Heat Snack Stick

This delicious lebanon bologna is sliced and ready to go for making sandwiches or just snacking on!  Pile it high on your favorite bun or roll it up and enjoy!

Sweet Lebanon Bologna

This item is $4.75 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 175 and 250 lbs.
The estimated price is between $831.25 and $1,187.50

Price is calculated from hanging weight. The final price estimate DOES include processing/cut & wrap fee.

Fill your freezer with premium steaks, hearty roasts, ground beef, and specialty cuts like brisket and osso buco for your friends and family! Orders are typically ready for pickup 14-20 days after initial processing date. You will be notified when your order is ready for pickup.

1 Quarter Beef (Anytime 2024)

This item is $9.00 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 5.5 and 8 lbs.
The estimated price is between $49.50 and $72.00

The perfect choice for BBQ hobbyists and professionals. Briskets have a lean flat cut and fatty point, this makes them the ideal choice for corned beef or BBQ.

Beef, Brisket (large)

This item is $9.00 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 2.5 and 5.5 lbs.
The estimated price is between $22.50 and $49.50

The perfect choice for BBQ hobbyists and professionals. Briskets have a lean flat cut and fatty point, this makes them the ideal choice for corned beef or BBQ.

Beef, Brisket (Small)

Unit size is per 1.12 lb pack

Perfect for your next delicious burger. Freshly ground into 3-6oz convenient patties.

Beef, Burger Patties

This item is $9.00 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 2 and 4 lbs.
The estimated price is between $18.00 and $36.00

The chuck roast is a very tender and lean cut from the shoulder of beef. Rich in flavor and can be cubed, stewed, braised, or used in a pot roast.

Beef, Chuck Roast

This item is $10.00 per lb.
The estimated weight is between 0.5 and 1.5 lbs.
The estimated price is between $5.00 and $15.00

Beef cubes are perfect for soups, stews and kabobs!

Beef Cubes

Yoder-way Farm 

Jeremy

Each week you will receive 4 pounds of nutrient dense beef and pork and 1 dozen eggs. There will be a rotating variety of bacon, sausage, hamburger patties, pork chops, steak, and ground beef. Something to please everyone in your family!

Weekly Farm Box

Beef, New York Strip

A variety of our beef and pork cuts! You will receive loose sausage, sausage grillers, ham slices, pork chops, bacon, ground beef, hamburger patties, steaks, and roasts! This meat box is also available as a monthly subscription. Set up your subscription for either delivery or farm pickup. Each month you will receive your meat box with out any further action needed on your part! Search for the 10# meat box subscription in the online store.

10# Meat Box-beef and pork

Fresh, local milk guarranteed for you every week! Pickup at the farm or we will deliver to you on Thursdays! This milk is bottled fresh on 2 farms in Mifflin County, The Reedsville Creamery and Horningford Creamery. If you would prefer one over the other just drop us a note and let us know! Just put in the amount of gallons you want and each week we will have that amount designated for you!

Weekly Milk Subscription

80/20 ratio. Pastured ground beef from happy cattle that enjoyed the positive benefits of the soil and the sunshine! A staple in our family's diet!

15# 1/2 Case Beef, Ground

Pastured beef brisket with the fat trimmed! 

Beef, Brisket 6.5 lbs

Great Comfort Food! Pastured chuck roast is perfect paired with carrots and potatoes.

Beef, Chuck Roast 2.5 lbs

Our most popular steak! 2 steaks per pack.

Beef, Delmonico Steak

The pastured porterhouse is the granddaddy of steaks! Boasting large portions of tender filet and loin, the porterhouse is a steak lover's dream!

Beef, Porterhouse Steak 2.5 lbs

Beef, Short Ribs 1.3 lbs

Mitchell Homesteading

Blaise Mitchell

Quail Eggs

Duck Eggs

Baked cookies to order, currently available:
Oatmeal white chocolate chip, chocolate chip, peanut butter, sugar.

Baked Cookies to Order

Place a deposit with us for whole quail. 
Hormone, medication free, raised consciously and sustainably, organic practices. 
When placing deposit please list how many you would like. $6 per bird, deposit is 50% of total. 

Quail - Whole Birds

4 to an order. Options are blueberry, peach, chocolate chip, blueberry/white chocolate chip, strawberry. Can be divided half and half. 

**Season Permitting for produce. 

Muffins

Field of Dreams Homestead 

Stephanie

Non-gmo, pasture raised eggs.  Sold by the dozen.

Eggs

Non-gmo, hormone and antibiotic free, consciously raised chicken.  Processed on our farm.  Sold frozen.  

Non-gmo, pastured chicken 

Starkweather Happy Hens

Elizabeth

Washed chicken eggs

Unwashed chicken eggs 

Valley Road Farm

Heather

Our farm fresh eggs are collected, washed and refrigerated daily. They are fertilized with 2 roosters onsite and our flock contains an average of 25 laying hens. 

Farm Fresh Eggs (by the dozen)

Big Hen Energy

Alexis

Experience the unparalleled taste of farm-fresh eggs from Big Hen Energy in Hadley, New York. Our pasture-raised hens, including lively breeds like ISA Browns and Speckled Sussex, roam freely on 11 lush acres, producing eggs with rich, golden yolks and firm whites. Grown with care using high-quality feed and sustainable practices, these fertilized brown and green eggs are a delicious testament to our commitment to quality and freshness. Perfectly suited for any meal, our eggs bring the vibrant essence of local agriculture directly to your table.

12 Best Baked cookies Farms in Webster, New York

There are 12 local farms in Webster, New York. Support local farmers and shop for fresh, seasonal goods right in your community.